What’s the Hurry?
For a faster, stronger you, take it slow (with a grain of salt)
Heading out the door? Read this article on the new Outside+ app available now on iOS devices for members! Download the app.
FOR A STRETCH, it appeared as though slow-motion strength training—better known simply as Super Slow—would take its place alongside the fleeting exercise fads of yesteryear (OK, it was only two years ago—but it seems like forever). The claims sounded outrageous: Spend just 20 to 30 minutes, twice a week, doing traditional lifts at the speed of continental drift, and you’ll build strength 50 percent faster than you would with conventional resistance training, kick your metabolism into high gear, reduce body fat, and raise your levels of HDL (the good cholesterol). When the hype over Super Slow quickly died down to a murmur—for reasons to be explained—people soon glommed on to the Next Big Thing (wobble boards, anyone?).
But it turns out that a handful of curious athletes and researchers stuck with Super Slow’s program and, facing incredulity from their peers, now swear by its effectiveness.
My own cynicism remained intact until I began trying to crash into shape for an upcoming kayak expedition that, if I hadn’t been ready for it, could have become a lesson in boat-bound misery. Fortunately, I ran into Renjit Varghese, 32, a largely self-taught exercise trainer and owner of Time Labs, a new five-story downtown Manhattan facility devoted to slow lifting. Born in Kerala, India, and raised outside Cincinnati, Varghese has been slow-training former pro athletes and business professionals for six years. Varghese contends that slow training is superior to multiple-set, clean-and-jerk approaches because (1) it eliminates the ballistic movements that cause many weight-room injuries; (2) strength improvements come faster; (3) you spend far less time in the gym, leaving more time for your sport; and (4) it’s more precise—you keep a record not of the number of reps, but of the exact amount of time your muscles are stressed, known as “time under load,” or TUL.
After following Varghese’s program for six months, I realized that at least some of Super Slow’s claims are legit: I shed ten pounds and toned up my legs, chest, and arms. During my ten-day kayak trip above the Arctic Circle in Norway, I found I could pull through the chop for hours at a stretch. My body recovered faster between paddling days, and I even had better control of my breathing—a welcome asset when I came close to panicking in rough, freezing seas.
THE IDEA FOR SUPER SLOW came in 1982, when Ken Hutchins, a 50-year-old entrepreneur from Conroe, Texas, pioneered the technique after conducting a study at the University of Florida Medical School. Armed with $3.5 million from the Nautilus Corporation, Hutchins sought to devise a weight-training regimen that increased the bone density of retirement-age women who had osteoporosis by building their muscles and improving their circulation without harming their joints. On a hunch, Hutchins had the women lift relatively heavy weights very slowly over extended periods. It worked. Some of the women in the study actually dispensed with their walkers and took up ballroom dancing again.
Convinced he’d hit on a breakthrough program suitable for all ages, Hutchins published a 1989 how-to manual, Super Slow: The Ultimate Exercise Protocol, and began building his own custom exercise equipment.
The word spread, and by the dawn of the 21st century athletes of all types (and fitness trend-watchers) had embraced the idea. At the elite level, 20-year-old professional trials biker Jeremy VanSchoonhoven took up slow training during last year’s off-season. After three months of slo-mo lifting, VanSchoonhoven had put on seven pounds of lean muscle. “This sounds ridiculous, but my whole workout is only about 15 minutes long, once a week,” he says. “But now I can compete longer at a top level, and I make fewer mistakes late in competitions.” His increased strength helped him place 16th—the highest finish ever for an American—at this year’s UCI World Championships.
Last summer, Jason Watson, 30, a Washington State Patrol SWAT team member, took home seven swimming medals from the Can-Am Police-Fire Games after slow training, sometimes only once a week, under Greg Anderson of Seattle’s Ideal Exercise. While such results are tempting, beginners should take note: This efficiency involves a sadistic level of intensity. At first, Watson had to pop a Tums before each workout just to keep from puking.
SUPER SLOW IS NOT without its critics. “I don’t like it,” says fitness consultant and six-time Ironman champ Dave Scott. “Especially if you’re an endurance athlete. Imagine you’re this lean runner strained under this huge, unnecessary load. You come to the gym, you’re already fatigued, and now you have to drop your weights 20 pounds to do just one rep: How do you stay motivated? It can be psychologically destructive.”
Wary of the opinions expressed by road warriors like Scott, I nevertheless signed up to be trained by Varghese, following Ken Hutchins’s original protocols. According to Hutchins, each exercise should be 10/5 per rep—that is, ten seconds on the positive contraction, or push, and five on the return, or negative contraction. (By contrast, a typical rep might be 1/1, 2/4, or 4/4.)
During my workouts, I do exactly one set of as many reps as I can until my muscles fail completely. At the end of each rep, Varghese tells me to make the transition from easing the load down to pushing it back up imperceptibly. Any faster and I’m using momentum to cheat. All along, Varghese reminds me to take controlled, quick breaths: “Pant like a sprinter.” Holding my breath, he tells me, will just make me dizzy. At the end of the set, my muscles feel torched by a fresh, white-hot rush of lactic acid.
Because of slow lifting’s difficulty—one Super Slow chest press can be harder than ten quick ones—the program suffers a high rate of attrition—another reason it’s no longer the fitness flavor of the moment. Wayne Westcott, fitness research director at the South Shore YMCA in Quincy, Massachusetts, has conducted two studies on slow lifting. The results, published in the June 2001 Journal of Sports Medicine and Physical Fitness, indicated that, yes, single-set slow lifters realized a 50 percent greater increase in strength over eight to ten weeks than did those lifting weights at a faster pace. However, only two of Westcott’s 147 test subjects opted to continue the slow-lifting regimen.
“The psychological aspect is just as important for a successful fitness program, and this was just too tough,” says Westcott, who adds that slow lifting is perhaps best applied as a plateau buster. “Do it for six weeks. But then return to what you’re more comfortable with week in and week out.”
Positive testimonials and my success with slow lifting aside, Westcott and Scott do have a point. The happy medium may be to see it not as strength training’s silver bullet, but rather as a valuable addition to your arsenal of fitness techniques. Periodically fold it into your existing routine (see “The Slow-Motion Workout,” next page) and you’ll soon reap the performance rewards. “There’s this kind of undercurrent in Super Slow circles that almost makes us sound antisports,” says Ideal Exercise’s Anderson. “But the point of its high intensity is to give you more time to play, and better results when you do.”
USE OUR SIX-WEEK slow-training program to bust out of a midseason plateau, or as a ten-minute preseason strategy for building strength and stamina. To get started, grab a stopwatch, find a gym with strength training machines for the exercises listed below (free weights are too dangerous), and enlist a partner to clock you. For each exercise, record the amount of weight used and your time under load (TUL)—the elapsed time from when you start the exercise to when you can no longer continue. When choosing a weight for each exercise for the first time, select an amount that allows you to reach muscle failure in no less than two minutes.
Start by breathing deeply and engaging the weight so it barely starts to move. Now complete the positive phase of the movement over five to ten seconds, until your joints nearly lock out. Pause momentarily at the upper turnaround and then reverse direction, taking five to ten seconds to lower the weight. At the lower turnaround, slow down further, so that the weight hardly touches the stack, and then start the next repetition. Focus on moving gracefully, not forcefully, continuing until it becomes impossible to move the load. When, after time, TUL reaches two minutes, increase the load by 10 percent.
Give yourself a minimum of 48 hours’ rest between workouts. And it’s a good idea to lay off slow strength training a week or two prior to a major competition. At the same time, wait 48 hours after an all-day ride or backcountry ski, and up to seven days after a triathlon, before resuming Super Slow training.
Be sure to breathe continuously throughout the set with controlled breaths. “Every one of our clients has said that learning to breathe throughout the exercises has helped them remain calm and strong under pressure,” says Varghese.
(First Two Weeks)
TUL goal: 2 minutes per exercise Frequency: 2 times/week
(Weeks Three to Six)
TUL goal: 2 minutes per exercise
Frequency: 2 times/week
off-season: 3 times/week
Alternate A and B routines on successive days
A. Leg press
B. Leg curl
(for more workouts see www.timelabs.us)